Cryptocurrency Q&A
Why is Elrond not High King?
Why is Elrond not High King?
Sebastiano
Sun May 26 2024
|
7 answers
1495
Why, then, is Elrond not High King? Given his illustrious lineage, being descended from the royal houses of both Noldor and Edain, shouldn't he be the one to occupy the throne of Gondor or Arnor? His wisdom and prowess are renowned, having played pivotal roles in numerous critical events throughout Middle-earth's history. Moreover, his residence in Rivendell, a haven for many seeking wisdom and guidance, further underscores his status as a leader of men. So, what prevents Elrond from ascending to the position of High King? Is it a matter of personal choice, or are there external factors that preclude him from this honor?
7 answers
Ilaria
Tue May 28 2024
The Ñoldorin's diminished numbers made it impractical for them to maintain a monarchy. Instead, they looked to figures like Elrond to provide leadership and direction in a time of uncertainty.
Was this helpful?
56
95
GinsengBoostPowerBoost
Tue May 28 2024
Elrond descended directly from Turgon, but his lineage traced back through his daughter Idril. Unlike his ancestors, Elrond never made any claim to the throne. Instead, he exercised absolute authority in Rivendell, much like a king.
Was this helpful?
281
50
BlockchainBaronessGuard
Tue May 28 2024
The Ñoldorin population in Middle-earth had significantly dwindled during the Third Age. This decline was a contributing factor to the kingship remaining unclaimed. The once-grand Ñoldorin dynasty had seen its glory fade with time.
Was this helpful?
45
69
Caterina
Tue May 28 2024
Despite the absence of a formal king, Elrond's wisdom and leadership were widely recognized. He guided Rivendell with a steady hand, ensuring its safety and prosperity. His reign was marked by peace and prosperity.
Was this helpful?
302
67
Chloe_thompson_artist
Tue May 28 2024
Elrond's lineage, although noble, did not automatically entitle him to the throne. His decision to rule Rivendell without claiming the kingship reflected his humility and commitment to the welfare of his people.
Was this helpful?
236
41
Load 5 more related questions
